Comments on: Book of the Week – Favorite Haiku: Brief Essays 1975-1998, Volume 3 by H. F. Noyes https://thehaikufoundation.org/book-of-the-week-favorite-haiku-h-f-noyes/ Mon, 02 Feb 2026 18:24:42 +0000 hourly 1 By: Keith Evetts https://thehaikufoundation.org/book-of-the-week-favorite-haiku-h-f-noyes/#comment-166356 Mon, 02 Feb 2026 18:24:42 +0000 https://thehaikufoundation.org/?p=75864#comment-166356 I find Noyes very perceptive. He concluded that the essence of haiku was its ‘spirit.’ That notion is of course hard to pin down, and for being non-academic, frustrating for some. But I think he was right. It’s not its form nor its conventional ‘crafting.’ A couple of quotes:

“Out of the rule-free informality of the haiku form, with its emphasis on intuition, will emerge a poetry truly fresh, with a spirit uniquely unbound”
— H F Noyes, Haiku Magic, essay Frogpond XXI.3 and RMA 1999

“Haiku is surely the most elusive form of poetry. Every time one tries to define it, the “rule” is broken in the same week by one of our best haiku poets. But art in all its forms is mysteriously elusive to some degree. Artists are always trying to convey the how of their success, and their explanations are generally of little help to the beginner. What is most vital is that we expose ourselves to the spirit of the art form. The spirit of haiku lies most of all in its simplicity and in its selflessness. Both are a way of life requiring real commitment and depth of understanding. “
—H. F. Noyes “The Way of Haiku” Presence 14 & RMA 2001 “The Loose Thread”

]]>